• Search by team or stadium name:

Buy the latest issue of Stadium Journey Magazine - Subscribe Today!

Stadium Journey Sports Magazine Subscriptions

Dwyer Stadium

Batavia, NY

Home of the Batavia Muckdogs

3.1

3.1

Dwyer Stadium (map it)
299 Bank St
Batavia, NY 14020


Batavia Muckdogs website

Dwyer Stadium website

Year Opened: 1939

Capacity: 2,600

There are no tickets available at this time.

Reviews

Local Information

Share
this

Muck in Name Only

Dwyer Stadium (named for Edward D. Dwyer, a long-time president of the Batavia ball club) encompasses a field that has been used for professional baseball in Batavia, New York since 1939. The current 2,600 seat incarnation was erected in 1996 and is primarily the home of the NY-Penn League Batavia Muckdogs, the only in-place charter franchise of the league, and owner of one of the most memorable monikers in minor league baseball. In addition to giving a home to the Muckdogs (for the last two years the short-season, single A affiliate of the Miami Marlins, after long affiliations with the Cardinals and Phillies), the park also hosts games for Genesee Community College teams, as well as local high schools.

While the neighborhood is strictly small town New York State and the park is showing its age in places, Dwyer Stadium serves up a good, affordable baseball experience for families and baseball fans alike.

3.1

What is FANFARE?

The FANFARE scale is our metric device for rating each stadium experience. It covers the following:

  • Food & Beverage
  • Atmosphere
  • Neighborhood
  • Fans
  • Access
  • Return on Investment
  • Extras

Each area is rated from 0 to 5 stars with 5 being the best. The overall composite score is the "FANFARE Score".

Food & Beverage    3

Dwyer Stadium has a good selection of food and drink, especially for a short season A-ball field. The main concession area is located in the home plate plaza by the main entrance, along with a beer concession, a small treats concession by the kids area, and a beer-and-peanuts stand under the third base bleachers.

The main concessions deliver standard ballpark and regional fare, including Zweigles' red and white hot sausages, burgers, fries, pizza, and chicken. The choice of the grub has got to be the Muckdog Signature Dog (red or white hot with "Muckdog Sauce" and onions for a reasonable $3.50). Or--how can you resist?--"Muckdog Chow," a red hot, white hot, burger, or cheeseburger, served on top of macaroni salad and homefries, smothered in Muckdog Sauce, and served in a big plastic dog bowl, all for $5.75.

Small and large Budweisers are available at most concessions for $4 or $5.50 respectively, and the specialty beer concessions serve up Southern Tier Farmers Tan, Rohrbach's Muckdog Red Ale, Rohrbach's Highland, Genny Light, and Brooklyn Summer Ale for $4.75 for a small and $6.50 for a large. The beer booths also deliver 16-oz cans for $5, and 25 ounces for $7. You're at their park, so you might as well give the fine Muckdog Red Ale a try.

Atmosphere    3

Dwyer Stadium has one main entrance to the right of the ticket booth. It opens out into an entrance plaza behind home plate on the first base side in a wide walkway that runs from outfield to outfield outside of the seating area, with two openings at first and third base. Both walkways end in tented picnic areas just before the home and visitor bullpens and clubhouses, in left and right field respectively.

The only cover in the park (besides those tents) is the seats under the grandstand behind home plate, which is topped with the press box. The gates open an hour before game time, and home team fans can seek autographs at the dugout on the third base side. Wherever you're sitting, you'll have a good view of the field and the open sky beyond the outfield walls.

Mascot Homer, the dog, and the fan relations crew run the between-inning entertainment, which includes the minor league standard races, quizzes, and contests. One unique event during my most recent visit was a lucky young fan getting to hit the owner in the face with a shaving cream pie, which showed the good-natured relationship between the team management and the community.

All that said, there are signs of wear around the park that need addressing. The scoreboard has seen better days and is missing some lights; the visitors' clubhouse in right is missing an "I" in its sign, rendering it "Vistor" and the sound system in the bleacher seats is reminiscent of the NYC subway speakers in the 80s; nearly unintelligible.

Neighborhood    2

The park is located as part of a neighborhood Little League complex, which gives you an idea of the surrounding area. It is very much in a small town in Western New York, and perhaps the best you can say for Batavia is that it is under an hour drive to both Rochester and Buffalo. In town, there are a couple of standard small-town historical attractions, the Batavia Downs Racetrack, and the Darien Lake Amusement Park is a short drive out of town.

Meat-lovers are in luck, as there are quite a few steakhouses and BBQ places in town, including Larry's Steakhouse, T.F. Brown's, Center Street Smokehouse, and Alex's Place.

Bar stops include Tully's, O'Lacys, and City Slickers. For those with kids (or kids at heart), Oliver's Candies (with hand-made chocolates, candies, and ice cream) is a must-visit downtown. A surprising amount of chain hotels are mostly right off the NY Thruway, including Best Western, Comfort Inn, Hampton Inn, Quality Inn, Super 8, Days Inn, Clarion, and Red Roof Inn.

Fans    3

A regional holdout from when seemingly every little burg in Western NY was home to a NY-Penn League franchise, Batavia still seems to have a good deal of local enthusiasm for its team. "Muckdogs Home Tonight" lawn signs are regularly seen while driving around town, and they still put in a respectable showing in the park.

The fans are mostly local families and not baseball purists, to be sure, but they are involved with the game and show support for their local pride and joy as you might expect.

Access    4

Batavia is an easy exit off the NY Thruway (I-90), as well as state roads 98, 63, 33, and 5. A large, free parking lot is right next to the stadium, and additional parking is also free in the adjacent parks. It is under an hour to both Rochester and Buffalo, and Batavia is about 2.5 hours to Toronto, and four hours to Albany or Pittsburgh. Those not driving can take the Batavia Bus Service Route 2 or 3 from downtown to the UMMC Station ($1), and a small regional airport (Genesee County) is north of town.

In the park, an inner walkway in the seating area splits the box seats below from the general admission seats above, and a wide outer concourse runs from outfield to outfield around the diamond to get people where they need to be.

Return on Investment    4

The strength of minor league ball is its value for the dollar, and the Muckdogs are no different. Box seats are $7.50, and general admission seats are $6.50, so there's no sticker-shock there. Coupon books of eight games are available for both kinds of seats and bring the cost per game down to $5.75 and $4.75 respectively for box or GA seats. Group rates for 20 or more get the price down to $5.50 per person, and all-you-can eat seats are available on the Hot Corner picnic area for $15 or $17.50 per person, with slightly expanded menu choices for the higher amount.

Nearly all the food items (even the special items) are under $5. Small beers go for $4, and 20 oz cans go for $7, and the large specialty beers don't top $6.50. It is just an affordable experience all around.

Extras    3

For a low minor league park, Dwyer Stadium has a more than average amount of extras. In addition to the standard stadium commemorative plaques (on the outside of the park by the ticket window), there is a revamped Batavia Wall of Fame and three plaques dedicated to Batavia as the birthplace of the NY-Penn League, Gene Baker (first black manager in professional baseball), and Whitey Loos (local baseball star in the 40's and WWII casualty) on the main concession building. A boosters' plaque is by the main entrance, and a small art installation called "I Am Someone in the Crowd" is located on the back of the home third base bleachers. The press box behind home is dedicated to Wayne H. Fuller (long-time PA announcer).

A small shed by the main entrance houses the team store and fan relations booth, and a modest kids area is located down the right field line. Booths sell programs in the main entrance plaza, and in a nice tip of the hat to scorers, a slanted resting shelf is located underneath the game lineups to make it easier to prepare your scorecard.

Final Thoughts

Dwyer Stadium is full of little surprises for the visitor and provides a straight-forward, cost-conscious evening of baseball for all comers.

Nice Review

Enjoyed the review Andrew am looking forward to seeing this nice little ballpark in a couple of weeks.

by pderrick | Jul 11, 2011 10:36 AM

Royalty Tours USA

Great review! I'm going there in a few weeks for the very first time. I can't wait. By reading this, I know exactly what to expect. Thanks for the heads up.

by Prince | Jul 13, 2011 09:42 AM

one of the crown jewels of the ny-penn league

Batavia is one of my favorite places to watch a game, the food is outstanding, while the merchandise stand is small, it does have a wide selection. I love the feel of an old neighborhood ballpark. Fans are the best and tickets are easy to come by.

by schaasy | Aug 05, 2012 10:35 PM

You must be a Stadium Journey member to post a comment.

Already a member? Sign in or Create a Stadium Journey Account

-- OR --

Crowd Reviews

The Batavia Muckdogs at Dwyer Stadium

Total Score: 3.57

  • Food & Beverage: 5
  • Atmosphere 2
  • Neighborhood: 3
  • Fans: 3
  • Access: 4
  • RoI: 5
  • Extras: 3

Opened in 1939, Dwyer Stadium is home of the Batavia Muckdogs, the short season Class-A affiliate of the St. Louis Cardinals. Batavia's baseball history actually goes back to the late 1800's, and the city has been a mainstay of the New York-Penn League for decades. The old Dwyer was actually largely demolished in the mid 90s, and a new $3-million facility was built in its place.

A Royal take on an Old School Ballyard

Total Score: 4.29

  • Food & Beverage: 5
  • Atmosphere 3
  • Neighborhood: 4
  • Fans: 4
  • Access: 5
  • RoI: 4
  • Extras: 5

Thanks to checking the review beforehand I was already knew what to exxpect once I finally stepped foot in this old ballyard. It was a great experience to go back in time to see a game in a real baseball setting. The Stadium was located right in the neighborhood which reminded me of Wrigley Field. They had a great food selection at reasonable prices. Unfortunately I had just eaten breakfast so I was too full to indulge. I saw a 11AM game where there were alot of kids and senior citizens amongst us real baseball fans. It turned out to be a fun day. I'm glad I finally got to experience baseball on the farm in Batavia. I suggest if you happen to be in the area that you see it for yourself.

A nice little diamond in the rough

Total Score: 2.57

  • Food & Beverage: 3
  • Atmosphere 3
  • Neighborhood: 2
  • Fans: 2
  • Access: 4
  • RoI: 3
  • Extras: 1

A decent ballpark, nothing extremely special. This is exactly what anyone would expect with single A Penn league ball.

Certainly Feels like a Lame Duck

Total Score: 1.86

  • Food & Beverage: 3
  • Atmosphere 1
  • Neighborhood: 1
  • Fans: 2
  • Access: 4
  • RoI: 2
  • Extras: 0

The Muckdogs have perennially been one of the worst draws in the NYPL, so it is only a matter of time before they head for green pastures. Unfortunately, you can almost feel the sense of resignation from the team and fans when you attend a game here. Dwyer Stadium offers nothing special as it is essentially just some metal seating sections setup around a field. While it is charming to have minor league ball in these small outposts of western New York, I much prefer the atmosphere in Auburn and Jamestown. For my full review, check out my website : http://ballparkreviews.com/template2.php?in_name=Dwyer%20Stadium%20II&in_city=Batavia&in_state=New%20York

Share your thoughts about Dwyer Stadium

Local Food & Drink

The Red Osier  (map it!)

6492 East Main Street Road

Stafford, NY 14143

(585) 343-6972

http://www.redosier.com/

Settler's Restaurant  (map it!)

353 W Main St

Batavia, NY 14020

(585) 343-7443

http://www.settlersrestaurant.com/

Center Street Smokehouse  (map it!)

20 Center St

Batavia, NY 14020

(585) 343-7470

http://www.centerstreetsmokehouse.com/

Larry's Steakhouse  (map it!)

60 Main St

Batavia, NY 14020

(585) 343-3400

https://www.facebook.com/pages/Larrys-Steakhouse/131559893533510

T.F. Brown's  (map it!)

214 E Main St

Batavia, NY 14020

(585) 343-1547

http://tfbrowns.com/

Alex's Place  (map it!)

8322 Park Rd

Batavia, NY 14020

(585) 344-2999

http://www.alexsribs.com/home/

Oliver's Candies  (map it!)

211 W Main St

Batavia, NY 14020

(585) 343-5888

http://www.oliverscandies.com/

Local Entertainment

Batavia Downs Racetrack  (map it!)

8315 Park Rd

Batavia, NY 14020

(585) 343-3750

http://www.bataviadownsgaming.com/

Darien Lake Amusement Park  (map it!)

9993 Allegheny Rd

Darien Center, NY 14040

(585) 599-4641

http://www.darienlake.com/

Lodging

Red Roof Inn Batavia  (map it!)

8204 Park Rd

Batavia, NY 14020

(585) 343-1000

http://www.redroof.com/

w

© 2014 Stadium Journey